Easy Perfectly Roasted Turkey with Just 4 Ingredients

Jump to Recipe

Easy, Perfectly Roasted Turkey is truly the simplest and I believe the tastiest way to cook a thawed turkey. This method lets the true flavor of the roasted bird speak for itself. I’ve roasted somewhere around 40-50 turkeys in my life, some in a cooking bag, some deep-fried, but most straight up in a roaster with a lid. This is my favorite.

Easy, Perfectly Roasted Turkey
Read more: Easy Perfectly Roasted Turkey with Just 4 Ingredients

Deep fried is super delicious, but quite a bit of work and it can be dangerous. The cooking bag made for a very juicy bird, but the skin isn’t crispy and we now know plastic, when heated, leaches chemicals into the food. Enamelware, ceramic coated, and stainless are the best for cooking and roasting.

Key techniques for success include:

Skip the brine bucket!

You can stuff the inside of the turkey with quartered lemon, onion, and herbs but I never do. I need the turkey broth to be pure and untainted by any flavors that will ruin the turkey broth needed for amazing Old-Fashioned Rolled and Cut Dumplings and Old-Fashioned Bread Dressing.

Let the turkey rest uncovered on a cutting board for at least 30 minutes to let the juices redistribute, preventing dry meat when sliced. If you need to cover it to keep it warm while making other dishes, tent it with foil (don’t touch the turkey skin with the aluminum). Remove the foil and reheat for 10-15 minutes right before serving to re-crisp the skin. You can use an injector filled with melted butter/broth in hidden spots to add moisture if it looks dry. Mine never do, but I’m just saying, you can if you feel the need. 😉 Most importantly, don’t overcook the turkey. That’s what leads to dry, tough meat.

perfectly roasted turkey with slices of succulent breast meat on a bed of dressing

Thawing and Preparing Your Turkey

If your turkey is frozen, begin thawing a full 24 hrs or more before you plan to start roasting. With the turkey still packaged, place in a plugged sink or bucket large enough to  cover the whole turkey with cold water. Change the water every couple of hours. If you thaw your turkey 7 days ahead of time, place, still sealed in its plastic in the refrigerator until you’re ready to prepare it. Less than 7 days in the fridge never thawed my turkeys enough to pull the bag of giblets out of the cavity.

Once thawed, or if roasting a fresh turkey, pull the bag of giblets out and roast them alongside the turkey. They will help flavor the broth. Or save them and use for giblet gravy. (I’ve never made it, but I’m sure you can find a recipe on the net.) Thoroughly pat the skin dry before roasting to ensure crispiness. Cut 1 stick of butter into pats and liberally salt and pepper so when you slide them under the skin, it seasons the meat as it melts and seeps into the flesh.

If You’ve Waited Too Late to Thaw Your Bird, See Here!

Easy, Perfectly Roasted Turkey

Easy, Perfectly Roasted Turkey

Culinary Craftiness
These directions are for roasting fresh or thawing a turkey at least 24 hours before roasting. You don't need any fancy herbs or need to stuff the cavity with aromatics – unless you want to! And no need to brine!
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 4 minutes
Total Time 4 hours 10 minutes
Course Main Course
Cuisine American
Calories

Ingredients
  

  • 1 thawed free-range turkey any size – follow the instructions on the turkey packaging for the number of minutes per pound at 325℉
  • 1 stick of organic salted butter
  • Organic extra virgin olive oil spray
  • Kosher salt
  • Organic ground black pepper
  • Large enamel or stainless steel roasting pan with lid or electric roaster

Instructions
 

  • Remove the turkey from the packaging and remove the neck and giblets bag from the cavity. You can add these to the roasting pan for extra flavor in the broth or save them to make giblet gravy, or throw them away.
  • Cut the stick of butter into slices and liberally season with salt and pepper.
  • Pat the turkey dry with paper towels then place in pan or roaster, breast side up. Carefully pull up the skin from the flesh from the butt end, sliding your fingers in to separate.
  • Slide the pats of butter in as far as possible. Stick a couple of pats under the wings. Spray the top of the turkey with oil and liberally salt and pepper the outside skin. Throw some salt and pepper inside the cavity if possible.
  • Cover and roast according to the package directions.
  • If roasting in the oven, remove the lid the last hour of roasting. Increase the heat to 400℉. Baste with pan juices and return to oven and let the skin brown and get crispy. If using an electric roaster that has a removeable pan, uncover, baste with pan juices and carefully slide into the oven on the lowest rack for 30-60 minutes, until the skin is to your desired crispiness.
  • Save the broth and drippings to flavor Old-Fashioned Dumplings and/or Old-Fashioned Bread Dressing. Or use for giblet gravy.
  • Let the roasted turkey sit, uncovered, for 30 minutes before slicing and serving.
Keyword Crispy, Easy, Holidays, Roast, Succulent, Tender, Turkey
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

How to Perfectly Roast a Thawed Turkey

a plate of thanksgiving side dishes with sliced turkey and gravy
Easy, Perfectly Roasted Turkey Pin

Serving Suggestions and Related Recipes

For more traditional Thanksgiving dishes that use simple ingredients with flavorful, old-fashioned techniques, check check out Old-Fashioned Candied Yams, Old-Fashioned Rolled and Cut Dumplings, and Old-Fashioned Bread Dressing.

And don’t forget the dessert! Old-Fashioned Pecan Pie, and a couple of twists on old favorites such as Pumpkin Gooey Butter Cake and Pumpkin Pie Crunch will round out your holiday dinner table!

Happy Thanksgiving 🦃 and Happy eating! 😋


Discover more from Culinary Craftiness

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Got a question or a thought? Share it!