Buttery Whipped Potatoes have taken fifty years to perfect. My first batch of potatoes was an absolute disaster. Way too much milk made them puddle on the plate, and not enough butter to elevate the taste to something worth remembering. Of course, I was just a little girl way back then learning how to cook. I’ve easily made 600 pots now and I’ve learned a thing or two. My mashed potatoes are whipped with lots of real butter, rich heavy whipping cream, and an electric mixer until they’re unbelievably smooth, creamy, and dreamy—the kind of comforting side dish that makes any meal feel like it was made with love.

For rich, whipped style with lots of butter and cream, Yukon Gold potatoes are my top pick. They have a medium starch level, a naturally buttery flavor, and dense, uniform flesh that produces a silky, creamy mash without turning watery or gummy. I don’t remember exactly when bags of these potatoes started appearing at my local Marsh and Krogers, but I first started using them in my Smoked Sausage, Potatoes, and Green Beans. No need to peel those! And no need to peel these unless you’re looking for a beautiful presentation. And of course, now we have to pay attention to pesticides on our fruits and veg so peel under running water if not using organic.
Russet (Idaho) potatoes are another great option — they’re the starchiest common variety and make a lighter, fluffier pot. They absorb dairy like a sponge, which works well with heavy cream.
A 50/50 mix of both is a good compromise if you have both on hand. I wouldn’t go out and buy both unless you just want to experiment. Don’t use the waxy kinds like red potatoes, fingerlings, and new/baby potatoes. They just turn gluey.


Buttery Whipped Potatoes
Ingredients
- 5 lbs organic yukon gold or russet potatoes See Note
- 1 stick organic butter
- 1/2 cup heavy whipping cream
- 1/3-1/2 cup whole milk
- 1 tsp salt
- 1/4 tsp black pepper
Instructions
- Peel and cut potatoes into small, uniform chunks. Cover with at least 1" of cold water in a large stainless steel or ceramic coated stock pot or dutch oven. Add a tablespoon of salt to the water.
- Turn the heat to high to bring to a boil, then reduce the heat to medium. Cook the potatoes in until a fork breaks the chunks apart when poked (15–20 minutes).
- Drain well and return to the hot pot and use an electric hand mixer or transfer to a stand mixer bowl.
- Add 1/2 the stick of butter, all the cream, and 1/3 of the milk. Beat on low to combine, then medium-high until light and fluffy. Add salt and pepper to taste while mixing. Add more milk if not creamy enough, but be careful not to make them to runny.
- Leave in pot or transfer to a serving bowl. Dot with tablespoon pats of butter. The heat of the potatoes will melt the butter into delicious pockets.
Notes



Clearly all these pictures of mashed potatoes were from various different dinners. I don’t make them from scratch as often as I used to since it’s just Jimmie and me at home now. But at Thanksgiving, homemade is an absolute must. The coolest thing is, all three of the boys are incredible cooks and make them now taking that labor of love off my plate. However, they all add roasted garlic taking them to a whole new level!
My recipe is for the traditional buttery whipped potatoes like my momma taught me to make. She only used milk, but the heavy cream is where’s it at – plus a lot more butter. 😉
These rich and comforting mashed potatoes are perfectly paired with Old-Fashioned Rolled and Cut Dumplings. The two naturally go hand-in-hand.
Happy eating! 😊
Discover more from Culinary Craftiness
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
